Ice Vest vs Phase Change Vest — Which is Right for You?
Share
If you're shopping for a cooling vest in Australia, you've probably noticed two main technologies: ice vests and phase change cooling vests. Both are effective, but they work differently and suit different situations. Here's a clear breakdown to help you choose the right one.
What is an Ice Vest?
An ice vest — like the Arctic Heat Body Cooling Vest — uses panels filled with crystal gel that absorb cold from a freezer. You freeze the vest for a couple of hours, put it on, and the gel panels draw heat away from your body as they slowly warm up.
Pros of Ice Vests
- Strong, intense cooling sensation
- Lightweight and flexible — can be worn under clothing
- No rigid packs or bulk
- Fast to put on
- Lower purchase price
Cons of Ice Vests
- Require a freezer to recharge
- Cooling duration is typically 45–90 minutes depending on conditions
- Temperature is not constant — starts cold and gradually warms
What is a Phase Change Cooling Vest?
Phase change vests — like the Inuteq Dexter or Gunner Hybrid — use PCM (Phase Change Material) packs that maintain a fixed temperature as they transition from solid to liquid. They're available in multiple temperatures: 6.5°C, 15°C, 21°C, and 24°C.
Pros of Phase Change Vests
- Constant, predictable temperature throughout the cooling cycle
- Longer cooling duration — typically 2–4 hours
- Recharge in cold water, a fridge, or a freezer
- Multiple temperature options for different needs
- No electricity required — ideal for remote locations
Cons of Phase Change Vests
- Heavier than ice vests due to the PCM packs
- Higher purchase price
- Packs require some time to recharge (30–60 min in cold water)
Which Should You Choose?
| Situation | Recommended Vest |
|---|---|
| Multiple Sclerosis or heat sensitivity | Phase Change (21°C or 24°C) |
| Pre-cooling before sport | Ice Vest or Phase Change (6.5°C) |
| All-day workplace cooling | Phase Change (15°C or 21°C) |
| Cycling or running | Bodycool Xtreme (evaporative) or Phase Change |
| Chemotherapy scalp cooling | Arctic Heat Cooling Cap (ice-based) |
| Budget-conscious buyer | Ice Vest |
| Remote or no freezer access | Phase Change (recharges in cold water) |
Can You Combine Both?
Yes! The Gunner Bodycool Pro Hybrid combines both technologies — PCM packs for sustained cooling with an evaporative outer layer for additional heat dissipation. It's the vest used by athletes at the Tokyo 2020 and Paris 2024 Olympics.
Still Not Sure?
We've been helping Australians choose the right cooling vest since 2012. Contact us and we'll recommend the best option for your specific situation.